Most Indian investors who started a SIP through a bank relationship manager, an app, or an agent are quietly paying more than they need to. They are likely holding the Regular plan of their fund, when a near-identical Direct plan of the same scheme charges a lower fee every single year.
That fee gap looks tiny on a monthly statement but compounds into a meaningful difference over a decade or two. This guide explains why direct plans cost less, what switching actually involves (it is not a simple toggle), the tax and exit-load catch, and how to decide whether moving an existing holding is worth it.
Regular vs Direct: why one is cheaper
Every mutual fund scheme in India offers two variants. The Regular plan is bought through a distributor, agent, or advisor who earns an ongoing trail commission. That commission is not billed to you separately — it is baked into a higher Total Expense Ratio (TER), the annual percentage the fund deducts from your investment.
The Direct plan is bought straight from the Asset Management Company (AMC), with no distributor in the middle. SEBI mandated direct plans from January 2013 precisely so investors could avoid paying commission they did not need. Same fund manager, same portfolio, same NAV movements — only the expense ratio differs.
How big is the gap?
For actively managed equity funds, the difference between the regular and direct expense ratio is often roughly 0.5% to 1% per year. On a debt fund it tends to be smaller. You can see both numbers on the scheme's factsheet or on any AMC website. A lower TER means a higher NAV growth for the same underlying portfolio, which is why the direct plan's NAV is typically a little higher than the regular plan's over time.
What that fee gap costs you over time (illustrative)
The table below is illustrative only — it assumes the same gross return and a fixed 1% TER difference, which will not match any real fund exactly. It is meant to show the shape of the impact, not predict outcomes.
| Years invested | Regular plan (lower net return) | Direct plan (higher net return) | Illustrative difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | Smaller corpus | Slightly larger corpus | Modest |
| 10 years | Smaller corpus | Noticeably larger corpus | Meaningful |
| 15 years | Smaller corpus | Materially larger corpus | Large |
| 20 years | Smaller corpus | Substantially larger corpus | Very large |
The point is simple: a 1% annual saving does little in year one but compounds into a large gap over 15-20 years because the saved amount also stays invested and grows. Over a long SIP, the direct plan can leave you with a meaningfully bigger corpus for the same money and the same fund. You can model your own numbers with a SIP projection on our calculators page.
The catch: switching is a redemption, not a toggle
This is the part most articles gloss over. Moving from regular to direct is not a setting you flip. Technically, you redeem (sell) your regular-plan units and make a fresh purchase of direct-plan units. That has three consequences.
1. It is a taxable event
Because you are selling units, capital gains tax applies on the gains in the regular plan, even though you are reinvesting in the same fund's direct variant. As of 2026:
- Equity funds: Long-Term Capital Gains (held over 1 year) are taxed at 12.5% on gains above ₹1.25 lakh in a financial year; Short-Term Capital Gains (held 1 year or less) are taxed at 20%.
- Debt funds: gains are added to your income and taxed at your slab rate.
2. Exit load may apply
If you sell units that are still inside the fund's exit-load period (commonly within 1 year for many equity funds), the AMC deducts an exit load — often around 1% — from your redemption value. Check the scheme's exit-load rule before switching.
3. ELSS lock-in blocks the switch
ELSS (tax-saving) units are locked for 3 years from each purchase date. You cannot switch units that are still inside their lock-in. You must wait until each tranche completes 3 years before moving it to direct.
How to switch, step by step
You can switch within the same fund house (regular-to-direct of the same scheme) or redeem and invest in a different direct scheme. Use any of these routes:
- AMC website or app: Log in, find your regular-plan holding, and use the "Switch" option to move to the same scheme's Direct plan. This is usually the cleanest route for a single fund house.
- RTA portals (CAMS / KFintech): Registrar and Transfer Agents service most AMCs. Through CAMS or KFintech you can place a switch across all the fund houses they serve in one place.
- MF Central: A jointly-run platform by CAMS and KFintech that gives a consolidated view of your holdings across AMCs and lets you switch to direct.
When you place the switch, always confirm the destination plan name clearly shows "Direct" (and "Growth" or "IDCW" as you prefer). It is easy to accidentally pick another regular variant.
Why not just stop and restart?
For your existing lump-sum or accumulated units, switching crystallises the tax now. For your future contributions, the cleaner move is often to stop the regular SIP and start a fresh SIP in the direct plan — no redemption, no tax event on the new money.
Is switching your existing holding worth it?
The trade-off is a one-time cost (capital gains tax, any exit load) versus a recurring annual saving (the lower TER, compounding for the rest of your holding period). A rough way to think about it:
| Situation | Lean towards |
|---|---|
| Long horizon left (10+ years), low unrealised gains, no exit load | Switching — the saving compounds for years and the tax hit is small |
| Large unrealised gains, units still in exit-load window | Wait — switch after the exit-load period; possibly stagger redemptions across financial years |
| Short horizon left (2-3 years) | Often not worth it — little time for the lower TER to recover the tax cost |
| ELSS units inside 3-year lock-in | Cannot switch yet; switch each tranche as it unlocks |
A practical sequencing tip
For equity funds, you get a ₹1.25 lakh LTCG exemption each financial year. If your gains are large, you can spread the switch across two or more financial years to use that exemption more than once and reduce the tax bill. This is a timing decision, not a reason to avoid switching altogether.
Before deciding, it helps to measure your fund's actual returns correctly. See our explainer on XIRR vs CAGR so you compare like with like, and browse the full mutual funds section to check direct-plan expense ratios.
The simplest rule for new money
Whatever you decide about old units, fix the leak going forward: start every new SIP in the Direct plan. There is no redemption, no tax, and no decision to agonise over — you simply select "Direct" when you set up the SIP on the AMC app, RTA portal, or a direct-plan platform. Over a 15-20 year SIP, this single choice can be worth a large chunk of your final corpus.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is switching from regular to direct really a taxable event?
Yes. Even though you stay in the same fund, switching means redeeming regular-plan units and buying direct-plan units. The redemption triggers capital gains tax on the gains in the regular plan.
How much lower is the expense ratio of a direct plan?
For actively managed equity funds the gap is often roughly 0.5% to 1% per year; for debt funds it is usually smaller. Always check both numbers on the scheme factsheet, as it varies by fund.
Can I switch my ELSS units to direct?
Only after each purchase completes its 3-year lock-in. Units still inside the lock-in cannot be redeemed or switched, so you move each tranche as it unlocks.
Will I lose money in the market by being out for a day during the switch?
A switch within the same scheme is processed at the applicable NAVs and is usually settled within a couple of business days. There can be a small gap, but for long-term investors this timing risk is minor compared with the recurring TER saving.
Should I switch old units or just start new SIPs in direct?
For new contributions, starting a fresh direct SIP avoids any tax. For existing units, weigh the one-time tax and exit load against the long-term saving — switching makes most sense when you have a long horizon and modest unrealised gains.
Where can I actually place the switch?
Use the AMC's own website or app, an RTA portal such as CAMS or KFintech, or MF Central. Choose the same scheme's plan that clearly says "Direct".
The bottom line: direct plans are cheaper for the same fund, and that edge compounds powerfully over time. For new money, always choose direct. For existing regular-plan holdings, switch when the long-term TER saving clearly outweighs the one-time tax and exit-load cost — and remember ELSS units must clear their lock-in first.
SIP Calculator
See how your SIP grows
- Project corpus for any monthly SIP amount
- Visualise the power of compounding over time
- Compare step-up SIP vs regular SIP